Saving costs and lives – a more strategic approach to breast cancer risk testing

October 28, 2021

One-size-fits-all approach no longer acceptable when genomic testing is available

A more selective approach to referring women with early stage breast cancer for costly international laboratory tests can create significant cost savings of up to 20%, and spare many women from the toxicity of chemotherapy, a recent publication from the University of Stellenbosch Business School (USB) has reported.


With more than 1.5 million cases of breast cancer diagnosed worldwide every year, it is the most common cancer that women are faced with today. More effective treatment has greatly improved survival rates but has also resulted in chemotherapy being advised to most patients, with many gaining no benefit.


The research conducted by Jaco de Jager as part of his MBA along with a team of researchers from USB, Stellenbosch University and private practise, analysed referrals of early stage breast cancer patients for the genomic test MammaPrint, which provides a genetic fingerprint of a cancerous breast tumour and accurately predicts the risk of the cancer recurring after successful surgery to remove the tumour.


Used worldwide, MammaPrint testing has identified a low-risk group for whom chemotherapy is not likely to add any further protection against future recurrence.


“A one-size-fits-all approach to breast cancer treatment is no longer acceptable in the genomic era,” said de Jager.


The test is performed centrally in The Netherlands, with a price tag in Euro, making it seemingly unaffordable in the ever-declining South African currency. In previously published work from South African and international researchers, it was reported that about half of patients with early-stage breast cancer may avoid the cost and toxicity of several months of cytotoxic chemotherapy by using MammaPrint. 


Several international studies from developed countries have shown its use to be cost-effective, but could the approximately R40 000 price tag for MammaPrint in South Africa be off-set by the approximately R107 000 cost-saving in chemotherapy if fewer patients needed to be treated?


The research team accessed anonymous clinical and pathology data of 583 patients referred for MammaPrint testing since 2007, when MammaPrint was first introduced in South Africa, and then used algorithmic models including “Predict” to classify the cases into clinically high- and low-risk.


Based on the historic use of MammaPrint in South Africa, they found that unselective referral has prioritised patients where chemotherapy might not have been indicated based on clinical grounds and that the addition of MammaPrint testing increased the total costs of care by 57%. 


“Based on clinical data, we found that performing MammaPrint testing for patients who were already at low clinical risk of needing chemotherapy adversely impacted cost effectiveness, limiting the widespread availability of the genomic test”, De Jager said.


“Overall, fewer patients would have needed chemotherapy, but the reduced cost of treating fewer patients was outweighed by the increased cost of having used MammaPrint testing in clinically low-risk patients who didn’t need the test.”


Their data was published in June in The Breast, a leading international, peer-reviewed breast cancer research journal. The research at USB is the first cost-impact analysis of genomic testing in breast cancer in South Africa.


The most important aspect of their publication showed that MammaPrint can be used in a cost-saving manner if testing is limited to only those patients where chemotherapy would be considered based on clinical grounds. This identifies about 50% of patients with a genetic low-risk result where the cost and toxicity of chemotherapy can be avoided. 


By adopting this de-escalating strategy, fewer MammaPrint tests would be performed, with a total saving of 19.5% in direct costs to medical aids. “Although not currently cost-effective with the historic referral pattern, the MammaPrint testing can be cost-effective in South African circumstances if a different approach is followed,” De Jager said.


De Jager, a pharmaceutical chemist with an MSc in Chemistry from the University of Stellenbosch, worked on a cost-benefit analysis of MammaPrint testing, from the perspective of both medical aids and patients, for his MBA research supervised by Prof Manie de Klerk of USB.


De Jager joined a research team of oncologists, pathologists and health economy academics led by oncology surgeon, Dr Ettienne Myburgh of the Panorama Centre for Surgical Oncology in Cape Town, to propose a more strategic, more cost-effective approach.


Genomic tests such as MammaPrint offer the promise of more individualised treatment and reducing uncertainty in making clinical decisions. In more developed countries they are considered cost-effective and are recommended by 93% of international breast cancer experts.


The researchers recommended that MammaPrint be used selectively in cases where a patient is (1) at high clinical risk and (2) the cancer sub-type is hormone receptor positive and human epidermal growth factor receptor-2 negative and (3) chemotherapy is being considered, and (4) where genomic testing could allow treatment de-escalation. 


They hope that managed care administrators in cancer care and medical aid schemes would use the data to adjust their approval criteria for MammaPrint testing, ensuring its sustainable use.


Together with Dr Myburgh, De Jager and Prof De Klerk, the research team consisted of private breast oncology practitioner Elizabeth Murray, Kathleen Grant of the department of biomedical sciences at Cape Peninsula University of Technology, and Maritha Kotze of the chemical pathology division in the Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences at the University of Stellenbosch.


Dr Michael de Villiers explains why people can become sick every flu season
April 21, 2025
Dr Michael de Villiers explains why people can become sick every flu season and why the influenza vaccine is generally recommended every year.
Dr Mpho Ramabulana stresses the importance of early detection of colorectal cancer.
April 11, 2025
Colorectal cancer, one of the most prevalent yet preventable cancers, can develop in the colon or rectum, often starting as small polyps that can quietly become malignant if left unchecked. Dr Mpho Ramabulana, a colorectal surgeon and gastroenterologist at Netcare Akasia Hospital, underscores the life-saving power of vigilance and the importance of early detection.
Cardiologist Dr Robert Routier and cardiothoracic intensive care unit manager Sr Nondumiso Fakude
April 1, 2025
Cardiologist Dr Robert Routier urges the public to check their personal risk factors regularly to help prevent or manage cardiovascular disease.
Obstetrician and gynaecologist Dr Natalie Odell
March 26, 2025
The physical strain pregnancy puts on an expectant mother’s body should not be underestimated. An obstetrician gynaecologist offers her insights for alleviating discomfort and promoting wellbeing with exercise and stretching throughout pregnancy.
Dr Patience Sigwadi
March 19, 2025
Dr Patience Sigwadi, a leading paediatric nephrologist practising at Netcare Unitas Hospital in Centurion, has issued an urgent call for increased focus on skills development to address the escalating kidney disease crisis among children in South Africa.
Paediatric Nephrologist Prof Rajendra Bhimma
March 11, 2025
Paediatric Nephrologist Professor Bhimma was recently awarded the Fellowship to acknowledge his extensive work in research, community-based outreach and teaching of paediatric nephrology, among others.
Prof Bhekifa Dube
March 7, 2025
Netcare congratulates Professor Bhekifa Dube on his invitation to join the European Society for Vascular Surgery's clinical practice guidelines committee. His selection as the only specialist from the continent highlights the significance of this achievement on the global stage.
Rare Disease Day on 28 February 2025
February 28, 2025
The lives of millions of South Africans with a litany of rare diseases can be vastly improved, and even saved, by addressing challenges in identifying, studying and treating their conditions. With Rare Disease Day on the 28th of February 2025, the Rare Diseases Access Initiative (RDAI) is driving an evolution of the country’s healthcare, through innovative strategies to better care for over 4.2million people living with an estimated 7000 rare diseases. “As our healthcare system faces significant changes in the years ahead, it is vital that we also advocate for people living with rare diseases in South Africa, especially those with limited healthcare access,” said Kelly du Plessis, CEO of Rare Diseases South Africa (RDSA), a member of RDAI. “As part of our ongoing research and awareness efforts, RDAI has conducted an initial analysis of the incidence and prevalence of rare diseases within the country.” This research will assist in improving access to healthcare, policy development, and patient advocacy, while giving critical insight into the challenges faced by patients. “According to research, some rare diseases affect fewer than 1 in a million people, while others, such as Down syndrome, cystic fibrosis, and haemophilia, have a more recognisable prevalence,” says Dr. Helen Malherbe, RDAI lead researcher on rare disease prevalence data. “Many conditions are undetected, underdiagnosed or misdiagnosed, with too many having no information available about them at all.” The RDAI was formed in 2019 to promote a more favourable environment for those impacted by rare diseases in South Africa. Participants include Ampath, the Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF), Discovery Health, Genetic Counsellors South Africa (SASHG), the Government Employees Medical Scheme (GEMS), Health Funders Association (HFA), Medihelp, Medscheme, North-West University (NWU), Rare Diseases South Africa (RDSA), the South African Medical Association (SAMA) and The South African Medical Technology Industry Association (SAMED). The Council for Medical Schemes (CMS) participates as an observer. In the same year, Rare Disease International signed a memorandum of understanding with the World Health Organisation leading to an international rare disease policy framework. In 2021, the United Nations General Assembly moved to adopt a resolution recognising 300 million people living with rare diseases worldwide. “A general lack of awareness and delayed diagnosis remain major hurdles for those affected by rare diseases. Policymakers and healthcare stakeholders need to prioritise access to treatment, diagnosis, and support for rare disease patients,” says Bada Pharasi, CEO of IPASA, “Through this initiative, working collaboratively with stakeholders at every level of the healthcare supply chain, we can bring real and meaningful change to those affected, including family members and care givers, through smart and efficient strategies.” The globally agreed definition of a rare disease is any medical condition with a specific pattern of clinical signs, symptoms, and findings that affects fewer than or equal to 1 in 2000 persons in a population. “Most are genetic, and some are inherited and passed down in families,” Malherbe says. “Some affect only the patient’s genetic recipe, while others may be acquired during life due to infection, trauma, or environmental effects. For many, the cause is still unknown. “These conditions mainly affect children, as they are largely incurable and many are life-threatening. Some require specialised and co-ordinated care, some have limited and expensive treatment options, while others have no information or effective treatments at all,” she adds. The RDAI is calling for a patient-centred care model built on equitable access, transparency and efficiency. Naturally, this model calls for the open participation of patients, the healthcare industry, health professionals, and the Government. “The most critical elements are robust diagnosis standards, improved access to treatment, data collection and management, co-ordination of care, measurement of outcomes and ongoing collaborative research,” du Plessis says. “We need to establish rare disease advisory committees, map gaps and opportunities, establish system requirements, create a roadmap and plan a phased implementation with clear timelines.” The RDAI states that these policy development steps would be a start in quantifying the disease burden and defining standards of care. This would be followed by building and strengthening the capacity to facilitate appropriate diagnosis, treatment, continuity and data monitoring. Thoneshan Naidoo, Chief Executive Officer of the Health Funders Association noted that, “We appreciate the unique opportunity provided by RDAI which enables stakeholders across the industry to work together and identify strategies that improve equitable access to the appropriate diagnosis, treatment and healthcare services for rare disease patients, in an affordable and sustainable manner, taking account of the other pressing needs across the healthcare system.” “True innovation in healthcare is only possible through partnerships and joint advocacy efforts that raise awareness and improve access to treatment. Our long-term goal is the development of a rare diseases policy framework and guidelines for coordinated care,” says Pharasi. “Our members are united in the commitment to unlocking improved patient outcomes and improving access to services and robust health needs assessment facilities.” he concludes. About RDAI The Rare Diseases Access Initiative (RDAI) is dedicated to advocating for improved healthcare access, policy development, and patient support for those affected by rare diseases in South Africa. The initiative brings together key healthcare stakeholders, including pharmaceutical associations, funders, genetic specialists, and patient advocacy groups, to drive impactful change. About RDSA Founded in 2013, Rare Diseases South Africa (RDSA) is a non-profit organisation advocating to ensure that people living with rare diseases and congenital disorders experience greater recognition, support, improved health service and better overall quality of life. Started out of personal need following the diagnosis of organisation founder, Kelly du Plessis' son, it became evident that there was a lack of awareness and support for rare diseases in general in South Africa. About IPASA The Innovative Pharmaceutical Association South Africa (IPASA) is a voluntary trade association representing 24 leading pharmaceutical companies committed to research, development, and innovation. Our mission is to drive healthcare advancement by advocating for policies that improve patient access to safe, high-quality, and affordable medicines.
Gastroenterologist Dr Barbara Makumbi explains the toll acid reflux can take on your health
February 26, 2025
Gastroenterologist Dr. Barbara Makumbi discusses common risk factors and offers tips for managing reflux and the longer-term condition known as gastroesophageal reflux disease (GORD).
Netcare St Anne’s Hospital emergency department now has both trauma and emergency  specialists.
February 19, 2025
From treating trauma injuries caused by wildlife, road accidents and sports, to heart attacks, stroke, or the sudden onset of other concerning medical symptoms – the emergency department at Netcare St Anne’s Hospital never sleeps.
More Posts